Meet Dr. Alison
My mother’s mother was a professional singer who spent most of her life in the chorus, my grandfather proudly beside her at every performance. She raised me on music and on the unshakable conviction that I had what it took. In my second year at the Yale School of Music, I finally heard what had actually gotten me there: an A-minus voice, carried the whole way by a grandmother’s love.
In music, a ghost note is one you feel more than hear. It took me years to realize I had grown up surrounded by them, and that I had missed most of the important ones the first time around.
Today, as a psychoanalyst, I spend my days listening for them: the quiet notes beneath what people say, where so much of what matters is carried.
Read More ⌄
Where the Story Begins
My parents were very young when they had me, so my grandparents helped raise me. My father’s father forged the papers that got people out of Nazi Europe, then filled his house with them. Later he faced down the mafia bosses who extorted grieving families for the right to bury their dead. His name was Dudley Feit. People called him Deadly Fate, with enormous affection.
I grew up listening to his stories. What I didn’t hear was my grandmother, standing quietly beside him and doing so much of the work of raising me that I was grown before I noticed. Both sides of my family had someone out front and someone beside them. It took me a long time to understand that the person beside is often the one keeping the song going.
Lessons from Addis Ababa
Early in my career, I led a ten-person mission to Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, and helped build a school for several thousand displaced people. The children kept washing our shoes to thank us, and we could not figure out how to refuse without hurting their feelings. I think now that we weren’t supposed to refuse. They were giving us something, and we were the ones who didn’t know how to receive it.
One night, ten men in trench coats came into our house with guns, and we were separated. I made up a rhyming song so the guards would think I was singing, while letting the others know I would be calling the embassy. (Nothing rhymes with embassy.) We were deported at gunpoint.
I have never known whether the guards understood the song. My team did. It was the first time I sang one thing and meant another on purpose, and the first time I understood that the message underneath reaches exactly the people who are listening for it.
Becoming an Analyst
For years I had been half-hearing something I couldn’t name. Interpersonal psychoanalysis gave it a language. A supervisor who had known the founders of the field, and who became my friend, taught me the idea I have built my work on: most of what goes wrong between people isn’t hidden. It’s unattended to. We steer around whatever would make us anxious, and we get so good at it that we call it a personality.
Every conversation has two layers: the one we’re having and the one underneath it. I think of the second as the ghost note. Musicians play ghost notes so softly that most listeners never notice them, but that’s where the groove lives. Without them, the song is correct and nobody dances.
The second conversation works the same way. It decides whether a client trusts you, whether a marriage feels warm, whether a child will tell you the truth, and whether a team follows its leader through a bad year, long before anyone says a word about any of it. The ghost notes are always there, carrying the meaning. Most of us miss them because nobody taught us to listen for them. I certainly missed my share.
For the people I work with, the ghost note is usually about competence. Their competence started early, as a solution to a household that needed someone steady or a parent who could only take in so much. I recognized it because it was mine. It worked, and it kept working. But a solution you find at nine is a narrow one, and over the years it starts making decisions for you. We get praised for the very qualities that keep us from being known. Excellence makes a good hiding place, partly because nobody thinks to look there. My clients often arrive competent, and it can take a year before one of them says something unrehearsed.
In the Business World
Once you learn to listen for ghost notes, you can’t stop, and I started hearing them at conference tables. A client asking about returns may really be asking whether she has finally done enough, and whether she can stop working without feeling she has let someone down. Wealth managers are trained to answer the question about returns. A client who only ever gets that answer feels handled rather than heard, and sooner or later she takes her money to someone who seems to understand her. Nobody at a quarterly review says, “I’m afraid my father was right about me.” They ask for another slide, then another, as if the right number could settle a question no number can answer.
Sometimes the ghost note gets loud enough to hear. A joke lands slightly wrong, or a detail slips out on the way to the door, usually just when the person is working hardest to look composed. I call that moment the Giveaway. It’s often the most useful information in the room, and it’s the subject of my book, The Giveaway, coming in Summer 2027.
Hearing it is a skill, and it can be taught. Today I train wealth managers, attorneys, coaches, and other client-facing professionals through The Depth Advantage, and I advise leaders and families when the conversation they’re having isn’t the one they really need to have.
Ghost Notes
Being loved is not the same as being found. I know how long a person can be good at something without anyone, including themselves, hearing what’s underneath it.
Every week on Ghost Notes, I listen for what goes unheard in marriages, families, offices, and the shows we can’t stop watching. Each piece arrives as an essay on Substack, with a podcast episode and a short film on YouTube to go with it. Once a month, I answer one of your questions.
I used to think of the chorus as where my grandmother ended up. I think now it was the point: a row of people listening for each other’s ghost notes, which is how people come to really hear one another.
Background & Training
